Democracy Dies in Darkness

Tana French’s ‘The Hunter’ defies the rules of suspense writing

In the Irish novelist’s new book, a sequel to ‘The Searcher,’ a retired American police detective is pulled into another case

Review by
March 6, 2024 at 8:32 a.m. EST
4 min

A glance, a grimace, a tightening of shoulders: Suspense is in the details — small details — scattered throughout Tana French’s new novel, “The Hunter.” These moments pile up until, in the novel’s stunning climax, the veneer of the mundane collapses, revealing the unthinkable that lies beneath.

“The Hunter” is the extraordinary sequel to “The Searcher” (2020), a novel that blindsided some of French’s longtime fans who were accustomed to the action of her Dublin Murder Squad police procedural series. (You need not have read “The Searcher” to appreciate “The Hunter,” though it helps.) Cal Hooper, the quiet hero French introduced in “The Searcher,” is a retired Chicago police detective who bought a derelict cottage in the west of Ireland precisely so he would never again have to chase down criminals or use his service weapon. He longed for what W.B. Yeats called “the peace [that] comes dropping slow” in the Irish countryside. What Cal should have known, however, is that evil doesn’t read the tourist brochures. The only thing that came “dropping slow” in “The Searcher” was Cal’s romantic illusion of rural life in Ireland.

A note to our readers

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.