Democracy Dies in Darkness

How the first Orthodox Jew in an MLB organization is making it work

By
Jacob Steinmetz, whom the Arizona Diamondbacks drafted in 2021, had a 1.89 ERA over a four-game stretch in August for the Visalia Rawhide. (Ron Holman/Visalia Times-Delta/USA Today Sports)
8 min

The second call was less important but only slightly.

The first had been historic. Two years ago, the Arizona Diamondbacks made Long Island high-schooler Jacob Steinmetz the first Orthodox Jew drafted by an MLB organization. It was a joyous occasion, but it was also scary.

Steinmetz was embarking on a career that might be at odds with his religion. Would he be able to keep kosher while making his way through the small towns that populate the minors? Would he be able to properly observe the Sabbath, abstaining from riding in cars and buses and using any kind of electricity? Could professional baseball and Orthodox Judaism coexist?