The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

In Broadway’s ‘Water for Elephants,’ circus parts are good, songs are meh

The new musical based on the bestselling novel incorporates acrobatics, along with puppets to portray animals

Shana Carroll, a founder of the Montreal collective the 7 Fingers, is credited with the circus design for “Water for Elephants” on Broadway. (Matthew Murphy)
4 min

NEW YORK — The new Broadway musical “Water for Elephants” looks patched together. In a good way.

After all, the Benzini Brothers’ Depression-era traveling circus, where the show is set, is no tiptop big top. The animals are malnourished, and some might be a little mangy. The performers form a tightknit skilled ensemble, but a few carry a lot of miles and seem a little weary. Both the tent and the traveling quarters are on the ragtag side. It’s only fitting, then, that the puppets representing the menagerie appear stitched from well-worn pieces, the company is made of disparate but complementary moving parts, and simple scaffolds bring to life an environment far from Ringling razzmatazz.