UkraineKupiansk sty

An informal memorial next to the former 'PMC Wagner Centre's St.Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russian Federation - 24 Aug 2023

HANDOUT on 6/9/2023

How U.S. military aid has grown since the start of the war

The Washington Post

UKRAINE YOUNG SOLDIERS

UKRAINE DRONES PRODUCTION

Wagner fighters deployed in Rostov-on-Don

Russia Ukraine War

The potent U.S. arsenal for Ukraine’s counteroffensive

Ukraine southern front

Promo image for russia-ukraine-frontline-map 

Ruble Sinks as Russia Isolated by Sanctions

Bloomberg

FTWP

HOGP

United States Russia Nuclear Treaty

Ukraine Russia War Crimes Hospitals

For The Washington Post

U.S. Army M1 Abrams tanks from the 1st Combined Arms Battalion, 163rd Cavalry Regiment prepare to conduct movement operations during Exercise Eager Lion in Jordan, Sept. 6, 2022

Task Force Spartan

handout

UKRAINE-RUSSIA-CONFLICT-WAR

Contributor

Respond to prefers-color-scheme dark in app web views

Follow section front redirects in Spectrum

Enable NLP source in PCS for load testing

Switch off the News Alerts Survey Widget when we have enough responses

Poll to determine if new LUF updates are available

Allows the winning A/B test variant to be turned on without Spectrum deployment

Show infinite scrolling sections in Assembler MultiView

Show option for NLP article summaries in Action Bar

Show NLP summaries collection recirc on article pages

A general feature flag for Recipe Features that aren't yet released

Feature flag for media team features that aren't yet released

Use new Orca video player for preroll plugin in Spectrum

Show the snow tracker (instead of the heat tracker) on Spectrum

Look to the cloud to protect the life documents saved on your computer

Can you spot bad financial advice on TikTok? Take our quiz.

5 myths about Social Security as the program faces a funding crisis

Miss Manners: Longtime friends lose minds over canceled dinner plans

Carolyn Hax: After holiday meals, guests rush the kitchen to claim the leftovers

Ask Amy: Retired couple misses social activities since the pandemic

The world’s coolest hotels want to tell you a story

6 Airbnb red flags to spot before you make a booking mistake

Some cruise prices are about to get a little more clear

Why this company’s biggest fans turned against it

These ISIS news anchors are AI fakes. Their propaganda is real.

Even remote and hybrid work can burn you out. Here’s how to avoid it.

Tariffs against China hamstring the transition to a clean energy future

The Post’s choices in Northern Virginia’s U.S. House primaries

States see legalized sports betting as a tax windfall — but at what cost?

No one is rocking in the ‘free world’

Kenyan president aims to attract green investment during U.S. visit

On Gaza, Biden is right and Netanyahu is wrong

Did Trump’s lawyers catch Michael Cohen in a ‘lie’? Let’s take a look.

Now playing off-Broadway: Trump’s synchronized sycophants

Trump’s courtroom enablers

Puppy abandoned with heart-rending note is adopted, named Minerva

Man, 91, shocks tiny firehouse with $500K gift: ‘Nobody knew how much I’d saved’

Retired cop meets abandoned baby he helped 23 years ago: ‘What are the odds?’

In photos: The scene in Houston after severe storms killed at least 4 people

Rep. AOC's 'people-first' approach

Rep. Delia Ramirez on organizing power and money

Bryce Harper, Joey Gallo and a bond forged by baseball since they were kids

Walter Johnson’s jersey from 1920 showdown with Babe Ruth is up for auction

A taco will always be a taco — no matter what we call it

Elections 2024 live updates: Biden continues outreach to Black voters; Trump heading to Minnesota

At campus protests, ‘DO NOT TALK TO THE MEDIA’!

CNN gets a presidential debate — and a much-needed win

Trump

Europe

World

National Security

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/ukraine-russia/

War in Ukraine

Andrei Gordeyev/Vedomosti

When Magomed Musaev, a Kremlin-connected tycoon, gathered friends in New York to celebrate his 60th birthday, he was joined at the head table by top executives from the Forbes Media Group. According to people who attended the June event, the revelers also included American tech founder Austin Russell, 28, who had recently announced that he was leading an $800 million deal to buy the storied media business.

Days before the party, however, Musaev had told associates that he was the Forbes buyer and had sealed the deal of a lifetime, according to five audio recordings and one video recording obtained by The Washington Post in which he discussed the deal.

“I just bought global Forbes,” Musaev told one of his associates, according to the material, referring to the Forbes Media Group, which includes the U.S. edition of the magazine. “You understand when you have in your hands the key to the most authoritative global brand, this key will give me access to anyone.”

Musaev repeated the claim again and again, according to the tapes. In one of the recordings, the videotape reviewed by The Post, he called Russell “the face” of the deal and insisted his own involvement be kept quiet. “I am doing it more subtly,” he said, according to the recording. “You understand,” he said at one point, “I am not working with a sledgehammer, nor with a scalpel, but with a laser.”

Musaev’s comments raise fresh questions about potential foreign influence in a major media deal, which has been a source of controversy for more than a year, attracting criticism on Capitol Hill and scrutiny by <a href="https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius" target=_blank>the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States</a>.

In a statement to The Post, Russell denied any involvement by Musaev or any Russian individuals in the deal. “Musaev has no involvement whatsoever in the Forbes transaction. Any suggestion to the contrary is false,” said a spokesperson for Russell. “There is not a single dollar of capital from any Chinese or Russian citizen or entity, including Musaev.”

It’s unclear from the tapes whether Musaev was describing himself as a kingmaker, rather than an investor, who had helped bring the deal together and would garner future influence from his role; whether he was a secret investor putting money into the transaction through others; or whether he was simply making false or exaggerated claims.

Musaev told The Post in an initial interview that any suggestion he had control of the deal was “absolute nonsense” and a “monstrous myth” and that “in the [deal] documents, in any written form, my participation is not there.” He denied he could have told his associates he had bought Forbes, but he did not respond to subsequent requests for comment about the tapes. In a later emailed statement, he said: “I have no investment in this transaction and no plans to invest in any way in the future, whether directly or indirectly.”

Axios reported in May, citing two unnamed individuals, that Musaev had brought Russell into the process to acquire Forbes, though it didn’t describe Musaev as an investor or buyer. Two executives familiar with the situation repeated this claim in interviews with The Post. Both Russell and Musaev deny that the Russian had any involvement in catalyzing the deal, according to Musaev and a person close to Russell. Russell courted potential investors in Silicon Valley and Hollywood over the summer — an attempt to bring in American ownership even as he maintained ties to foreign funders, according to four people who have worked with Russell on the deal, who, like others, spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe private business matters.

At the heart of the tangle of conflicting claims sits the relationship between an American tech boy wonder and an older Russian tycoon. In 2016, Musaev had helped land a $20 million seed investment in Russell’s then-fledgling company Luminar, according to court documents. That early stake was now the company’s second-largest outside shareholder, public financial filings from April show.

Best known for its business magazine, Forbes sports a sprawling series of online properties, along with a global franchise of glitzy conferences such as “30 under 30” and its rankings of wealthy business people.

Musaev holds the license to publish Forbes Russia, one of the dozens of local language editions of Forbes magazine that are part of the overall media group, and has close connections to some of the individuals reported to be investors backing Russell, according to a former Musaev business partner, Pavel Cherkashin, as well as three additional people familiar with the deal.

Russell’s bid for Forbes has attracted the attention of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, or CFIUS, according to two people familiar with the matter.

“They are 100 percent looking at it,” one of these people said in recent weeks.

CFIUS, led by the Treasury Department and made up of several agencies, has the power to probe certain U.S. business transactions for national security risks. It can push for changes or, in rare cases, ask the president to block a deal. CFIUS doesn’t disclose its decisions or even which transactions it is examining. “CFIUS does not publicly comment on transactions it may or may not be reviewing,” said a Treasury spokesperson.

Taylor Hill

In an <a href="https://www.cotton.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/forbes_letter1.pdf" target=_blank>Aug. 9 letter</a>, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) and Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) called on Treasury Secretary Janet L. Yellen — who chairs CFIUS — to review the deal, claiming that Russell was “masquerading as the lead buyer” while “it is evident that Russell is merely a conduit for larger foreign investors.”

The senators, who both serve on the Senate Intelligence Committee, asserted in the letter that the bulk of the money appeared to be coming from investors with foreign ties, including Shiv Khemka, a close Musaev associate who serves as vice chairman of an Indian conglomerate that has worked with the Kremlin. A Republican Senate staffer told The Post the senators’ letter was guided by research conducted on the sale by an Obama-era National Intelligence Council chairman, Greg Treverton.

In a memo circulated to policymakers on Capitol Hill in July and seen by The Post, Treverton cited information showing the deal’s foreign investors, including, he claimed, Khemka’s daughters, would contribute nearly 50 percent of the total $800 million purchase price, while Russell would be investing only a small fraction of that amount. “It appears there is a strong national security argument for the US Government to block the ... buyout,” Treverton wrote. Treverton declined to comment further when reached by The Post.

“It’s not in our country’s best interest to let a major U.S. media outlet be run by entities with ties” to countries such as Russia, Rubio said in a statement to The Post.

One person close to Russell’s team said “some of the accusations, arguably all of the accusations, produced in [the senators’] letter are false.”

Similar concerns about foreign influence were raised last year in a different iteration of a deal to acquire Forbes — which quickly collapsed.

That plan had been spearheaded by the Hong Kong-based Integrated Whale Media Investments (IWM), which bought Forbes Media from the Forbes family in 2014 and whose owner TC Yam is a Canadian citizen. IWM wanted to take Forbes public through a merger with a Hong Kong-based special purpose acquisition company or SPAC, Magnum Opus. But the deal was axed following concerns over Chinese government influence, <a href="https://www.cotton.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/forbes_letter.pdf" target="_blank">when four U.S. senators had asked Yellen to investigate</a>.

Forbes said at the time  it was terminating the Magnum Opus takeover amid strong growth that “significantly outperformed the financial targets provided at the start of the SPAC transaction.”

In a statement to The Post, IWM said: “Having conducted extensive due diligence on the buyer group being led by Austin Russell, we have uncovered no reason for concern with any investors involved in this deal.”

Russell’s announcement in May that he planned to buy Forbes was widely viewed as a surprise. So was the offer valuing Forbes at $800 million, which was $200 million more than the failed SPAC deal’s expected price. Some media analysts also balked at the price tag, noting it was more than the combined sale price of The Washington Post, Fortune and Time.

David Paul Morris

Russell declined to give The Post a precise breakdown of investment in the Forbes deal, saying he was legally bound not to disclose exact terms before the deal is signed, which is expected in November.

In a statement to The Post, Russell said he was “looking forward to seeing Forbes realize a new vision for capitalism, where companies create both economic value and value for the world at the same time.”

Last month, as The Post talked with Russell’s representatives, a new company created by Russell to make the Forbes purchase sent out a press release saying the $800 million transaction already had attracted “over $2 billion of demand” mostly from American investors. The release named eight of the investors, including the celebrities Tony Robbins and Kevin Hart. It noted that there were no Chinese or Russian investors in the deal.

But how much money they or anyone else, including Russell, would be investing was still undecided, according to the release, which noted “final investor allocations” would be decided “in the coming weeks.” And written communications, seen by The Post, appeared to show that in the days after the press release Russell’s team was still seeking to raise substantial amounts of financing.

A spokesperson for Russell told The Post that although “all capital required to complete the Forbes acquisition was contractually committed” when the deal was signed in May, Russell’s team had “continued to attract and engage with interested top-tier investors to expand the investor base.”

Representatives for Russell declined to comment on whether Khemka, the close Musaev associate, is an investor in the proposed deal.

Sun Group, the Indian conglomerate where Khemka serves as vice chairman, had originally been slated as the lead investor in an earlier version of the sale, according to a January financial document seen by The Post. But after U.S. lawmakers voiced concerns over Khemka’s perceived ties to the Kremlin, Russell took over as the head of the deal. Sun Group had initially agreed to provide about half the financing for the purchase, according to two of the people familiar with the deal.

In their August letter to Yellen, Cotton and Rubio alleged outright that Musaev had partnered with Khemka to acquire the publication. “Sun Group … has partnered with a Magomed Musaev, a former Kremlin propagandist, to acquire Forbes,” the senators said. The senators did not provide any evidence for that assertion.

Khemka lived in Russia for 25 years, according to public records, working with the Kremlin on pet projects such as the Skolkovo business school just outside Moscow, and serving for more than four years on the board of a key company within Russia’s state arms conglomerate RosTech, including after the United States imposed sanctions on it. He also developed a close relationship with Musaev, according to Cherkashin and three of the people familiar with the deal, and the two men were often seen together at social events and business gatherings.

Russell’s representatives disputed assertions by several people familiar with the deal that Khemka’s daughters, who are U.S. residents, had been forwarded as investors in an attempt to bypass concerns over foreign involvement in the deal. They insisted there was no connection in this deal between Musaev and Khemka.

Khemka did not respond to a request for comment, while one of Khemka’s daughters, Gayatri, 23, reached by The Post, said she was “not allowed to comment” on the sale.

Ever since the deal was announced in May, Russell has touted the acquisition as returning Forbes from its Hong Kong ownership to the United States, asserting that he would have 82 percent control of the media group’s voting rights, meaning that he would have the final say in major corporate decisions.

In the audio recordings, however, Musaev described the Forbes acquisition as a chance to grow his — and Russia’s — global standing, but did not want any attention to his role. “The main aim is silence and results,” he said in one recording.

Musaev insisted in the interview that he had not discussed the deal with any Russian officials, claiming he has not visited Russia for two or three years. Nor, he said, had he spoken to any Russian officials during that time.

But Musaev forged his career with the help of the connections of his father-in-law, a powerful former  leader of Dagestan, a Russian republic, who was appointed by Russian President Vladimir Putin. Musaev’s father-in-law until recently served as a special Russian envoy to the Organization of Islamic Cooperation.

Musaev had previously served in the Moscow city government, running a major exhibition center before becoming the senior city official for innovation. According to Cherkashin, Musaev had entered the close circle of a powerful Kremlin-connected billionaire, Suleiman Kerimov, also from Dagestan, through his father-in-law.

When Musaev’s company Global Venture Alliance made the $20 million seed investment in 2016 in Russell’s Luminar, it did so on behalf of a company controlled by Kerimov, Delaware court documents show. The stake in Luminar still held by Musaev’s GVA is now frozen by the U.S. Treasury because of U.S. sanctions later imposed against Kerimov, according to court documents from July 2023.

While that deal became a springboard to other investments in Silicon Valley, it was also the moment when Musaev and Russell became “friends,” according to Cherkashin, noting it was the first big injection of capital that Russell, then 21, had received.

Two years later in 2018, Musaev acquired the rights to publish Forbes Russia. A former senior employee noted that Musaev could not operate Forbes Russia without the Kremlin’s approval. “It is impossible nowadays for there to be a situation where the media does not communicate with Kremlin structures,” according to this former employee who spoke on the condition of anonymity for fear of retribution. “Otherwise, the ownership of the media has to be changed.”

Ever since Musaev acquired Forbes Russia, he began cultivating a relationship with the current owner of Forbes Media Group, TC Yam, eyeing the possibility of acquiring the global brand, according to Cherkashin, as well as an associate of Yam and an associate of Musaev. Musaev “had this dream to buy Forbes for a long time,” Cherkashin said.

Sarah Ellison contributed to this report.

Putin's People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Took On the West

Catherine Belton is an international investigative reporter for The Washington Post, reporting on Russia. She is the author of “Putin's People,” a New York Times Critics’ Book of 2020 and a book of the year for the Times, the Economist and the Financial Times. Belton has worked for Reuters and the Financial Times.

Catherine Belton

Gerald Loeb Award for Explanatory Reporting finalist, 2017 

John B. Oakes Award for Distinguished Environmental Journalism finalist, 2017 

Scripps Howard Environmental Reporting Award finalist, 2017

Great Plains Journalism Award for feature writing, 2014

National Headliners Award for feature writing, 2010

ASNE Jesse Laventhol Deadline News Reporting Prize, 2008

SPJ Sigma Delta Chi Award for feature writing, 2002

University of Delaware, BA in English

Todd C. Frankel is an enterprise reporter on The Washington Post's Financial desk. He joined The Washington Post in 2014 and previously worked as a reporter at newspapers in St. Louis; Everett, Wash.; and Charleston, W.Va.

Todd Frankel

Winner of the 2017 Overseas Press Club Bob Considine Award for "Behind the Firewall" Series on Silicon Valley China

 2010 Finalist, Livingston Award for Young Journalists

 2009 Finalist, Livingston Award for Young Journalists 

Columbia University, BA. 

Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, MS.

Lizza joined The Washington Post as Silicon Valley correspondent in 2016, becoming the paper's eyes and ears in the region. She focuses on social media and the power of the tech industry in a democratic society. Before that, she was the Wall Street Journal's first full-time beat reporter covering AI and the impact of algorithms on people's lives. 

Elizabeth Dwoskin

Russian tycoon claims he is behind Forbes purchase, audiotapes show

the-washington-post

FORBES SALE

Tass

Verified videos

Donbas region

Russian combat capabilities

HIMARS

washpost

prism://prism.query/site-articles-only,/business&limit=20

Get a curated selection of 10 of our best stories in your inbox every weekend.

Business

The source for business news and analysis. Covering economic policy, business policy, financial news, economic issues, stock market data, local business, technology and more.

prism://prism.query/site,/world/europe&limit=20

The Washington Post provides the latest information and analysis on UK and European news. Includes news from the European Union, European commission news and European parliament news.

prism://prism.query/site-articles-only,/world/&limit=20

The Washington Post World section provides information and analysis of breaking world news stories. In addition to our world news and video, Post World News offers discussions and blogs on major international news and economic issues.