The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

AI can now muddle its way through the math SAT about as well as you can

September 22, 2015 at 9:13 a.m. EDT
The system got a score of 500 out of 800 on the math section questions. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

Artificial Intelligence is kind of a scary concept, probably because we know that a robot smarter than us would run the numbers and be like "Humanity? Nah."

[Apple co-founder on artificial intelligence: ‘The future is scary and very bad for people’]

But the race to create an autonomous, intelligent computer is still ongoing. The latest potential step forward comes from the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence (AI2) in collaboration with the University of Washington, where an AI system has gotten a fairly average score (for a high schooler) on the math section of the SAT -- 500 points out of 800. That's about 49 percent accuracy, and comes quite close to the high school senior average of 513 points.

First, why that's not so astonishing: Computers are really good at math. In fact, you'd expect any decent computer to be able to breeze through all of the questions on the math section of the SAT.

[Stephen Hawking just got an artificial intelligence upgrade, but still thinks AI could bring an end to mankind]

Instead, the AI system called GeoS probably couldn't get accepted to the university that designed it, where the average math score is 580 to 700.

But here's the astonishing part: GeoS wasn't fed these problems in a language it could inherently understand. It had to read them straight off the paper, confusing diagrams and all, and interpret them the same way a human student would. After "looking" at the problem, GeoS uses the diagram and text to come up with a set of formulas that it "thinks" are most likely to correspond with the problem. Then, since those formulas are in its native tongue, the system is able to solve the questions handily. Once it has an answer it goes back to the multiple choice options and looks for one that matches its outcome.

You can see a demonstration of that problem-solving process here.

"Our biggest challenge was converting the question to a computer-understandable language," Ali Farhadi, an assistant professor of computer science and engineering at the University of Washington and research manager at AI2, said in a statement"One needs to go beyond standard pattern-matching approaches for problems like solving geometry questions that require in-depth understanding of text, diagram and reasoning.”

In the reported tests, GeoS wasn't always able to answer questions -- in fact, the system failed to come up with a solution about half the time. But when it was confident enough to answer, the system had a 96 percent accuracy rate.

[Here’s the argument for banning killer robots before we’re swarmed by them]

Farhadi and his colleagues believe that this demonstration shows a step toward true AI -- a computer brain that can work just like a human's -- even if it hasn't blown us out of the water yet.

But engineers generally disagree with one another when it comes to proving computer intelligence. Last year another group claimed to have passed the Turing Test -- where a computer can successfully pass itself off as human to another human -- and was met with much skepticism. A recent piece in New Scientist suggests that a single test for AI may be an antiquated notion. Instead, many researchers now believe, we should be working on copying and evaluating individual aspects of intelligence, and trying to put them together into one brainy computer.

GeoS seems to be making strides in some very important aspects of intelligence, but we'll have to wait and see just what the system is capable of. And it's far from ready to take its place as a robot overlord.

Read More:

Go ahead and break this robot’s legs. It can figure out how to chase you without them.

This new opera stars an autonomous robot (really)

Self-proclaimed ‘experts’ more likely to fall for made-up facts, study finds

Here’s the argument for banning killer robots before we’re swarmed by them

Stephen Hawking announces $100 million hunt for alien life